CapturedWings.org Forums

CLAMP's Famous Works => Cardcaptor Sakura => Topic started by: Arcademan on August 29 2005, 01:59 am

Title: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on August 29 2005, 01:59 am
Someone in another forum asked me this question. Have to admit...it was a good one and it took me awhile to figure out who would win if the two Syaorans went one-on-one with each other in a fight...winner takes all.

Go ahead and vote, then an explanation on why one would be victorious over the other. Of course, I also included a "Neither" option for those who may think the two would be enenly matched.
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Hori on August 29 2005, 02:01 am
I like the one from Tsubasa best .. Maybe its because I ' know' him better than the one from CCS ... and Personality wise I prefer him too ...
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: cute_me on August 29 2005, 03:51 am
i can't choose between them, i mean you have to admit that both of them are almost the same, the both are cute, sweet and the would do everything they can just to save sakura.

Cuteme, stop using shorthand, this is your last warning
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: moezychan on August 29 2005, 10:12 am
You really picked a hard question Arcademan/PixieP-san. It had me really got me thinking for quite a while, but I was able to come to a decision. I'll first give the pro's and con's of both Syaoran's and then tell you who I voted for.

CCS Syaoran Li Pro's: This Syaoran would be the obvious choice, for a number of reasons. For one, he knows martial arts, can fight with a sword, has the ability to use magic and when fighting, and he doesn't give up.

CCS Syaoran Li Con's: While he still has the ability to do all of the above, he lacks one ability. When Syaoran Li fights, he does it to the best of his ability but when Sakura is involved, he lets his emotions get in the way of his fighting. He often becomes jealous, protective, and nervous, and the fact that he is 11-12 years old, he doesn't completely understand his feelings, and this is his downfall.

Tsubasa Syaoran Pro's: This Syaoran also has a number of abilities. He is also able to do martial arts and he also is able to overcome a fighter with magic.

Tsubasa Syaoran Con's: The only weakness I can see is that he is blind in his right eye, but at the same time it is an asset. If Syaoran wasn't blind, Seishiro-san would have never taught him how to fight.

Those are my reasons and now I'll give my answer. If you asked me which Syaoran was my favorite from each show I would definately choose CCS Syaoran, but I won't explain why because that's off topic, but the Syaoran that would win the fight would be Tsubasa Syaoran. For one reason, even though he cannot use magic, he can win a fight against a person with magic. He has proven this many times, but the main reason would be that CCS Syaoran does let his feelings get in the way of battle. His emotions hinder him, and cause him to lose a number of times and it's not entirely a bad thing. For one, as stated, he is only 11-12 years old and is just starting to learn what real love is, while Tsubasa Syaoran, no matter what his emotions are, he doesn't let them get in the way of his fighting. It was a very tough question and I commend you for it Arcademan/PixieP-san. For giving me such a brain teaser, I'll give you a cookie!
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Moon on August 29 2005, 10:27 am
I agree with you, moezy-chan. Nicely done respond. *claps*
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Cherry-chan on August 29 2005, 10:31 am
What's shorthand?

For me... hmm... that would be a tough decision...

Arrrgghh... *sighs* Sorry to do this TRC Syaoran... but CCS Syaoran is better. But... my decision might change. One of the reasons I chose CCS Syaoran is because I've gotten so used to see him and grown to love his character. As TRC goes along (Actually, I'll always love Syaoran no matter where or what Anime he's in), I'll probably grow to love him a lot, too. So basically my decision was based on which anime I've seen more, and that's CCS.

Does this sound unfair or something? :(
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: moezychan on August 29 2005, 10:31 am
I agree with you, moezy-chan. Just a nicely done respond. *claps*

Arigatou Gozaimasu moonprincess18-san!

What's shorthand?

For me... hmm... that would be a tough decision...

Arrrgghh... *sighs* Sorry to do this TRC Syaoran... but CCS Syaoran is better. But... my decision might change. One of the reasons I chose CCS Syaoran is because I've gotten so used to see him and grown to love his character. As TRC goes along (Actually, I'll always love Syaoran no matter where or what Anime he's in), I'll probably grow to love him a lot, too. So basically my decision was based on which anime I've seen more, and that's CCS.

Does this sound unfair or something? :(

I hope I don't sound judgmental or critical; if I do just tell me. But your answer is unfair in a way. After you read this, please check out my above post.

If this test was on which was my favorite, I would pick Syaoran Li from Card Captor Sakura hands down, but don't ask me why in here because that's off topic, but the fact of the matter is the question asked which Syaoran would win the fight, not which one is your favorite. I'm done here, so please do me a favor and read my above post and you'll see why I chose my answer. Again, I hope I didn't sound too critical. If I did, I apologise for it.
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Moon on August 29 2005, 10:37 am
Your welcome. ^_^

@cherry : I'm guessing shorthand is where you don't type out all your words. Just shorten it up. *shrugs*
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Cherry-chan on August 29 2005, 10:45 am
ahh... I did not read the question right *turns bright red and runs away* I'm sooo stupid... I tend to make a fool of myself like this all the time. And naww...mozey-chan you didn't sound judgemental or critical... it's just a classic case of my stupidity. :(
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Cherry-chan on August 29 2005, 10:46 am
Oh, and moonprincess18, thank you for the explanation :)
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Moon on August 29 2005, 10:49 am
No problem. I tend to misread questions myself if that makes you feel any better, Cherry. I do it all the time actually when I don't mean to.  :sweatdrop:
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on August 29 2005, 10:49 am
It was a very tough question and I commend you for it Arcademan/PixieP-san. For giving me such a brain teaser, I'll give you a cookie!

Thank you. Actually if any thanks are to be given, it's to the person that asked me the question over at the Geoff Johns Comic Bloc Forum. BTW, here was my answer:

Quote
Syaoran from Tsubasa during his mission to gather Sakura's feathers has shown to be a strong and agile fighter, especially in the kicking area and has seen much battle.

Syaoran Li from CCSakura has trained in the martial arts, as well as swordsmanship and the casting of spells and mystical abilities. Unlike his doppelganger from the Kingdom of Clow, he doesn't have the on-hand battle experience.

For now I'd give the slight edge to Syaoran Li however in the last book (Tsubasa #6), Syaoran wanted Kurogane to teach him how to use a sword. Once he learns this, the advantage changes over to him.
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Cherry-chan on August 29 2005, 10:51 am
I'm sorry to post  three times in a row... but would it be alright for me to delete my.. erm... "answer" to the question? If no one minds...
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: moezychan on August 29 2005, 10:57 am
ahh... I did not read the question right *turns bright red and runs away* I'm sooo stupid... I tend to make a fool of myself like this all the time. And naww...mozey-chan you didn't sound judgemental or critical... it's just a classic case of my stupidity. :(

Don't worry, you're not stupid. I almost read it wrong as well, and it's ok to make mistakes. It's how you learn.
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Cherry-chan on August 29 2005, 11:03 am
Thanks... yeah... I guess it is how you learn :) Ah, and thank you again moonprincess18. I'm so glad I joined this forum... the people here are so nice...
Title: Re: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Moon on August 29 2005, 11:07 am
:thumbsup: Again, your welcome.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on August 29 2005, 11:25 am
Don't worry, you're not stupid. I almost read it wrong as well, and it's ok to make mistakes. It's how you learn.

I changed the title and altered the question so it should be easier for those who come by later to participate in the poll. Sorry for the confusion.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Ralea on August 29 2005, 11:30 am
For me, CCS Syaoran! Nothing can beat that attitude and martial arts!
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Okamirei on August 29 2005, 11:53 am
I fell in love with TRC's Syaoran-tatchi ; never really liked CCS' Syaoran..  :sweatdrop:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: charme.* on August 29 2005, 01:00 pm
i agree
though i like syaoran in ccs.. tsubasa's syaoran is way muuch stronger-- he even beats people who have magic..and is now learning to use a sword..
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: Adarian on August 30 2005, 04:12 am
Even though I like the Syaoran from CCS alot better, I have to agree that the Tsubasa Syaoran is too strong for him. Syaoran in Tsubasa has totally bad@$$ kicking skills, and he could easily find ways to counter the CCS Syaoran's magic.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: fisah on August 30 2005, 05:17 am
Well, this is a tough question Arcademan, so I'll try to show my reason as to why I chose Syaoran from TRC.

CCS!Syaoran is a strong character in martial arts, and knows how to use a sword. He also uses magic quite well. His emotions can be his downfall or his motivation.

TRC!Syaoran is also a strong character, who is more hands on than anything. He doesn't use magic, and has a strong will, and doesn't let his emotions sway him. He is learning how to use a sword.

Now, I also want to point out that CCS!Syaroan and TRC!Syaoran are pretty much the same, save for a few differences. TRC!Syaroan is much more older, can analyze situations much quicker, and can also beat one with magic. However, CCS!Syaoran has the same assets, except he isn't blind in one eye. So aren't they really on par? I dont know if it makes sense but CCS!Syaoran is just like TRC!Syaoran with magic, and he also isn't blind in one eye. If CCS!Syaoran was older, I'd say he'd be the strongest.

But, I'm choosing TRC!Syaoran because its good to have patience, and dont let your emotions sway you. TRC!Syaroan is also a quick learner and really smart, and he has shown countless times that he doesn't need magic to defeat one with magic. :haha:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Tooya_Mizuki on August 30 2005, 05:32 am
I havent watched Tsubasa yet but judging from the pictures
that I see of Syaoran in TRC, he looks way tougher than his
CCS counterpart  :keke:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: KatanaJon on August 31 2005, 08:34 am
CCS Syaoran can stop time.

That's all I have to say.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Moon on August 31 2005, 08:47 am
CCS Syaoran can stop time.

That's all I have to say.

True, but it can only last for so long. :/
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: Adarian on August 31 2005, 12:57 pm
And he lost that card during the final judgment. Exactly what time period are we talking? Like during the middle of the series? Is this before the CCS Syaoran lost his Clow Cards and before Tsubasa Syaoran learned how to swordfight?
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: xOLight_AngelOx on August 31 2005, 02:45 pm
i just think syaoran (tsubasa)would win he does look better
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: moezychan on September 02 2005, 02:37 am
CCS Syaoran can stop time.

That's all I have to say.

One thing to remember. Syaoran Li lost the time card in his battle with Yue, and after Sakura beat Yue she got the time card. She proves this when she uses it in episode 65: Sakura and the Snow-blowing Ski School and in the second movie she uses it against the Void Card.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on September 02 2005, 09:39 am
The Time is one of the most powerful cards (behind The Dark and The Light) however uses tremendous amounts of energy. Its powers are finite. BTW, the other card requiring lots of energy is The Return.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Ruby Chan on September 02 2005, 10:14 pm
CCS Syaoran would win, simply because he's better equipped to. Even though TRC Syaoran is older, CCS Syaoran would still be strong enough to win, because not only does he have martial arts skills, he can also wield magic, which is something that TRC Syaoran can't do. Plus, he's not blind in one eye.

TRC Syaoran couldn't beat the magic if he was being electrocuted, or drowned....and to those who might say he could resist the wind attack, remember how he was beaten by the Ryan'ban's magic wind!

No contest really.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on September 02 2005, 10:41 pm
CCS Syaoran would win, simply because he's better equipped to. Even though TRC Syaoran is older, CCS Syaoran would still be strong enough to win, because not only does he have martial arts skills, he can also wield magic, which is something that TRC Syaoran can't do. Plus, he's not blind in one eye.

TRC Syaoran couldn't beat the magic if he was being electrocuted, or drowned....and to those who might say he could resist the wind attack, remember how he was beaten by the Ryan'ban's magic wind!

No contest really.

All good and valid points. So far the CCS version has all the skills and training. The Tsubasa version seems to have more in-battle experience and the motivation for battle.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: moezychan on September 02 2005, 10:46 pm
In my opinion, I think experience beats training everyday. One can only know so much before they actually experience it first hand.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: card_master on September 05 2005, 08:31 pm
neither,to evenly matched.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Fye-chan on September 05 2005, 10:04 pm
CCS Syaoran use magic thats why I think TRC Syaoran would have his problems with him...
But if we see only the body strength TRC Syaoran would be the better one!!!
hmmm difficult... :tongue3:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on September 05 2005, 10:24 pm
For those who have voted...thanks :)

For those who posted their explanations on how such a battle would go...big thanks :D
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Sayora Chan on September 08 2005, 09:36 pm
I feel that TRC Sayoran would win anyway that you slice it.  The fight would be long and involved, but that would be the outcome.  There are too many variables concerning CCS Sayoran's power.  How many cards does he have?  This being the largest variable, if we were to give him the best cards he has throughout the series, then we would have to wait until TRC ends to give the other his best goodies.  It's like moezy-chan said, if I had to pick a favorite, then it might be CCS Sayoran, but in terms of combat abilities TRC Sayoran has it.   :boxing:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Zeldi on September 09 2005, 03:50 am
It´s kind of easy.. The CCS Syaoran is sweet and all... But it was the Syaoran (Tsubasa Version) i´m more obbessed with <3
The Tsubasa Syaoran is
~ Much cuter
~ Risks everything to Save Sakura :3 ( It would be better if he could save me *obbessed joke XD*)
Yeah you get it :3
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: bLuetopaz on September 10 2005, 09:32 pm
just thought that they will be evenly matched..

like most of you said, CCS Syaoran can use magic and sword.. and TRC Syaoran is a good fighter and later able to use a sword..

also, CCS Syaoran may be younger but i believe he can dodge attacks faster due to his small built.. and TRC Syaoran is determine and focus..

so.. its really evenly matched!
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on October 06 2005, 10:58 am
Looks like the Tsubasa version of Syaoran is beating his Cardcaptor Sakura counterpart by a 2-to-1 vote with 7 others saying it's an even battle. I'll keep the poll open until the end of this month, then I'll lock and load :)
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: suu_no_clover on October 08 2005, 05:56 am
Personally, I like trc Syaoran best, but I think ccs Syaoran would kick his ***. If Sakura was involved in the match, like if the loser loses their most precious person, then all bets would be off. Someone should write a fanfic about that!  :D That'd be totally awesome.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: sofiacardcaptors on October 09 2005, 01:56 pm
wii @@ It's difficult.. both are.... great! xD
;_; i can't choose xD
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: Robin Sena on October 09 2005, 11:43 pm
In the level of potential...

CCS - Has a static potential (powerful, but can't go even further).

TRC - Has unknown potential (weak at first, gains power at a specific rate).

The X - Zero formula works perfectly on the two.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: KanameChan on October 10 2005, 08:08 am
the way I see it....CCS!Syao has more experience as far as fighting goes....being trained in traditional martial arts (or was that only the anime?  I don't remember  :sweatdrop:), whereas TRC!Syao is only just beginning....but dang he has that "I'm gonna win or else" attitude, so that should keep him going....

They're evenly matched....well, assuming the battle takes place in a situation where they are both the same age, otherwise TRC!Syao wins simply because he's bigger  :tongue:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: Eriol on October 11 2005, 02:01 pm
Wow!!!This is a tough cookie and it's hard to decide but I already seen these two in their certain anime/manga versions in action and I decided both of them!!! :okay:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Robin Sena on October 11 2005, 03:45 pm
Formula wise - TRC definitely, his potential (unless CLAMP nerfs him) is unknown.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: angel_from_hell on October 12 2005, 03:52 am
This is a really hard question i think, both Syaoran from CCS and Syaoran from Tsubasa is good. But if i had to chose it would be Syaron from Tsubasa I like him more than CCS Syaoran i started to lik  Syaoran from Tsubasa right away I think he has more personality than from CCS   
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: monkey on October 12 2005, 04:39 am
I agree with what Robin Sena has been saying, Potential is a powerful weapon in itself XD
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: moezychan on October 12 2005, 05:12 am
I agree with what Robin Sena has been saying, Potential is a powerful weapon in itself XD

I agree as well. TRC Syaoran has much more to lose than CCS Syaoran, considering that even though TRC Sakura has magic, and so does CCS Sakura, TRC Sakura cannot protect herself, therefore TRC Syaoran has more to lose and this is what drives him to fight so well.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: suu_no_clover on October 12 2005, 04:15 pm
It's really up in the air. Potential could give trc Syaoran an advantage over ccs Syaoran, if Sakura's fate was involved.
Then there's the matter of swords. As far as sword power goes, ccs Syaoran would probably lose to Hien, regardless if it was just a sword fight. However if magic were involved.... AUGH! You could go on for hours! It's like that question "Which came first the chicken or the egg?". >.< I'm confused now.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on November 03 2005, 10:11 pm
Voting is now complete. Thanks to everyone who participated in this discussion and poll :)
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: babypigggy on November 04 2005, 07:41 am
TRC syaoran is hotter!
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: Cardcaptor Takato on November 04 2005, 08:44 am
I missed getting to vote, but I can still respond too, right?  Even though CCS Shaoran will always be my favorite, my vote has to go to Tsubasa Shaoran.  I think he can adapt to different situations better than CCS Shaoran can.  Take it look at the Hanshin world for proof of that.  When Shaoran gets the power of the Kudan, he learns how to use it very quickly.  He also learns how to use a sword pretty fast, too.  CCS Shaoran has magic but Tsubasa Shaoran was able to beat the bad guys that used hijitsu in Chun Yang's world before and hijitsu is similar to magic.  CCS Shaoran may have undergone martial arts training as a young boy in Hong Kong, but Tsubasa Shaoran also had training from Seishirou and he's had real-life experiences in battles before, too.  Plus, I think CCS Shaoran's life is a little bit sheltered to me, what with him always being groomed by his mother to be as perfect as he can be, always having a family to turn to, and in the anime he had Wei with him when he was in Tomoeda.  But Tsubasa Shaoran has experienced a little more hardship in life and the only person that ever raised him was Fujitaka, who died when Shaoran was just a teenager.  I just think that Tsubasa Shaoran could survive a fight to the death more than CCS Shaoran could because he's already handled a lot of hardships in his life and he knows not to let his emotions get in the way of battling.  His blind eye may get in the way of battling at first, but he's also starting to learn how to handle fighting with it better, too.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: ishiyaki on January 03 2006, 10:37 am
I'm confused
I like both!
ccs syaoran was so cute (when he was blushed) and sincere... :inlove:
trc syaoran has grown, he's stronger and more responsable...but he doesn't come blushed like before! :confused:
ouh....I really like trc manga syaoran :noteworthy:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Sya
Post by: Eriol on January 06 2006, 09:27 pm
Yeah!!And my truly vote is: Syaoran of Tsubasa Chronicles.Darn,he humble at the inside,tougher at the outside!!! :hehe:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Sohru-san on January 20 2006, 04:08 am
This is a really good question and that's hard to say but Sakura's magic is a lot more powerful then Syaoran's and she has more cards then him. They'd never fight though.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: lilaznrycegurl on January 20 2006, 04:57 am
I vote TRC Syaoran! ^__^v
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on January 20 2006, 10:27 am
This is a really good question and that's hard to say but Sakura's magic is a lot more powerful then Syaoran's and she has more cards then him. They'd never fight though.

BUZZ!!!! Wrong answer!!! Try Again!!! :tongue:

The question was "Who would win in a one-on-one fight between CCS's Syaoran Li and TRC's Syaoran?" Sakura isn't involved in the fight...except for motivational purposes :wink:
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: sam mogford on March 27 2007, 04:45 pm
TRC syaoran for me. he wont let anything get in his way.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on March 28 2007, 10:40 am
When this first appeared, the question was more of a toss-up. Now that Tsubasa has moved along, it's painfully clear the TRC Syaoran would have the upper hand in a fight against his CCS counterpart.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: sam mogford on March 29 2007, 01:46 pm
i agree arcademan plus syaoron moves so quick
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: muhi_kira on April 22 2007, 04:41 am
OMG!!! so difficult question
 i vote TRC syaoran ^_^
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Takeru on April 22 2007, 10:19 am
They both know martial arts, so that counts for something. TRC Syaoran's older, and most likely stronger and faster, so that may contribute. CCS Syaoran's younger, so he's a smaller target, and he also knows magic, which would definitely play in his favor. TRC Syaoran also has that flaming sword (Nietono no Shana, anyone?) and seems more adept with it, but he's also got that balance handicap going against him.

I say even match.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Robin Sena on April 24 2007, 02:04 am
TRC Syaoran's Base Rank is 0-32.

CCS Syaoran's Base Rank is 10-28.

In SHMUP analysis, CCS gets a jump in power but fizzles (see rank).
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on April 24 2007, 10:34 am
BTW I unlocked the poll for those who haven't voted yet ;)
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Kaze no Shikyo on April 26 2007, 09:12 pm
i believe that CCS syaoran would win because he has been studying martial arts for longer and his magic is more developed where as Tsubasa syaoran has been taught basics and developed his skills from there also his magic is the fire from huen (soz if spelt wrong) and it is rarely used as well as it being undeveloped.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Kurogane_Lover on December 05 2007, 09:29 am
This is a really hard question i think, both Syaoran from CCS and Syaoran from Tsubasa is good. But if i had to chose it would be Syaron from Tsubasa I like him more than CCS Syaoran i started to lik  Syaoran from Tsubasa right away I think he has more personality than from CCS   
I agree, so I voted for Tsubasa Syaoran.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Keichii on November 04 2008, 12:22 pm
I voted for TRC Syaoran.

His skills are the same with CCS Syaoran demo TRC Syaoran's skills are much more improved.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Qiara Koduki on December 20 2008, 12:03 am
TOUGH decision. I think I always said that to every question / poll. I want to say, that depends. Why? 'cause are we talking about Syaoran real or clone? If real then he automaticly equal. He got his skill from his father him self! Even the names are the same raitei shorai. And they both lean martial arts. If clone then.... hmm..... he have Fye's magic................ I rather not vote, but I already did!
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: marian hime on April 21 2009, 11:26 pm
I`d love to say even but Syaoran Li has a lot to learn.
Syaoran(tsubasa) was more trained than Li. Even if they are the same person, I`d say the older one`s better.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on April 22 2009, 09:42 am
Heh...old thread still gets new responses :)
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: light09 on June 15 2009, 01:28 am
hmm...to what I know and understand syaoran TRC and syaoran CCS are NOT the same person even the dimensions and stuff...they are not the same people.
the R.syaoran is actually the son of the syaoran and sakura from CCS. and the C.syaoran is ..well the clone syaoran of the real one. I digress..
back to topic,
i agree with what moezychan stated about syaoran CCS, but we forget about the age difference.
CCS syaoran is younger than TRC syaoran.I think the reason CCS syaoran lets his emotions get in the way is that...he was young and new to this strong affections for someone(CCS sakura). TRC syaoran is older, probably mid teens-late teens and so he would be more mature and more in control of his emotions.


as for who would win if they were at the same age...I think TRC/son syaoran would win b/c he is the offspring of two powerful magicians, descendant of clow..and son of card mistress. Magic-wise= TRC syaoran....fighting-wise...well in CCS it's a shojo ..so I didn't see much physical fighting from him ..whereas TRC is a shounen I saw lots of fighting from TRCsyaoran, that is also another point to notice....b/c we see more of one side fightin...stating who would win...in physical combat is difficult. Therefore for me to decide who would win would be biased cuz i would choose TRC syaoran.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: Arcademan on June 15 2009, 03:25 am
I pretty much think now the TRC version would most likely win but those finally finding this thread now and making comments...keep in mind the poll was made almost 4 years ago and since that time, the TRC Syaoran (R, C, XYZ, whatever!) has evolved in powers and abilities. The CCS version didn't have that option so one can only assume what his capabilities are after the CCS series ended.
Title: Re: One-on-one Fight: Syaoran Li (CCSakura) vs Syaoran (Tsubasa)
Post by: light09 on June 25 2009, 03:04 pm
Arcademan<--agreed

I made a mistake I meant to say magic-wise=CCS syaoran...
as for the new chapter that came out recently....i just want to say that Clamp is stirring up so many twists that i hope they can somehow resolve it..cuz it's running thru my mind about ...well who the heck came first?...chicken or the egg situation...it's like a loop...when did it actually begin?