CapturedWings.org Forums

CLAMP's Famous Works => Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE => Manga Chapter Discussions => Topic started by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 05 2007, 01:07 am

Title: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 05 2007, 01:07 am
cloud9alice's LJ: http://cloud9-alice.livejournal.com/43904.html#cutid1

gallery: http://pics.livejournal.com/cloud9_alice/gallery/0007d258

translations: http://mangahelpers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=22419
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sandra-chan on December 05 2007, 02:52 am
That was quick! Thanks for telling us :)
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Ando on December 05 2007, 05:18 am
Thanks for posting!

Show content
Did Sakura just call Syaoran by name?! As in, without any honorific?

I almost, almost find myself wishing he's done for this time. I don't know how many more "OMG Syaoran is dead111! No wait his determination compells him to rise again!" scenes I can take.  -__-

Please Sakura, won't you break free from the bubble thing already and kick some *ss with those supposedly awesome powers of yours? Anyone's *ss would be fine.

*waits anxiously for translations*
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Itzeen on December 05 2007, 05:55 am
THANKS!!!!
I really love the colored pages.........

Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 05 2007, 07:27 am
tnx. ill add that to the first post
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Kazemon15 on December 05 2007, 08:16 am
Thanks for posting!

Show content
Did Sakura just call Syaoran by name?! As in, without any honorific?

I almost, almost find myself wishing he's done for this time. I don't know how many more "OMG Syaoran is dead111! No wait his determination compells him to rise again!" scenes I can take.  -__-

Please Sakura, won't you break free from the bubble thing already and kick some *ss with those supposedly awesome powers of yours? Anyone's *ss would be fine.

*waits anxiously for translations*

lol

Show content
Well, Real Syaoran never had those moments as much as our clonie did, so he's an exception for that XD But wow....no honorfic? Does that mean she's starting to care more for the real Syaoran other than clonie?
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Ando on December 05 2007, 09:03 am
Show content
Well, Real Syaoran never had those moments as much as our clonie did, so he's an exception for that XD

Show content
Of course our Syaoran is in the lead in that department, and that's why I'm so thoroughly fed-up with cliffhangers like these: twenty-something volumes of (either) Syaoran almost-dying are quite enough. Well, that and the fact that we've been having scenes like these in pretty much every chapter as of late. R!Syaoran needs to have his character developed, not show off more of his fighting skills or unfaltering devotion.

Show content
But wow....no honorfic? Does that mean she's starting to care more for the real Syaoran other than clonie?

Show content
Even though I'm all C!Syaoran/Sakura, I must say it would appear to be it (unless it is a severe error on CLAMP's part, which seems quite unlikely). Mirroring the scene in CCS when Syaoran 'accidentally' calls Sakura by name when she's in mortal danger, maybe?
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Kazemon15 on December 05 2007, 10:03 am

Show content
Of course our Syaoran is in the lead in that department, and that's why I'm so thoroughly fed-up with cliffhangers like these: twenty-something volumes of (either) Syaoran almost-dying are quite enough. Well, that and the fact that we've been having scenes like these in pretty much every chapter as of late. R!Syaoran needs to have his character developed, not show off more of his fighting skills or unfaltering devotion.


LOL So true. 

Show content
Even though I'm all C!Syaoran/Sakura, I must say it would appear to be it (unless it is a severe error on CLAMP's part, which seems quite unlikely). Mirroring the scene in CCS when Syaoran 'accidentally' calls Sakura by name when she's in mortal danger, maybe?

Show content
Maybe, but it does make it look more dramatic without the honorfic. But CLAMP does tend to make a few mistakes, such as the whole right eye left eye thing too...well, only time will tell. It's now at the point where most fans love both Syaorans and want both to end up with Sakura, huh? ....maybe CLAMP is being evil and forcing us to chose to support in this battle XD
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 05 2007, 04:48 pm
....Eh, it's no mistake.
I'm so happeh! :DD

Show content
This proves to me that she's seen the part of Cloney that she fell in love with in R!Syaoran. Or, more specifically, she's seen "Our!Syaoran"/"Clow!Syaoran" in R!Syaoran. ♥♥♥
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Airashii on December 06 2007, 06:55 am
I wonder who she'll end up with! I mean it would be sad if C/Syaoran dies or the other way around!
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Ando on December 06 2007, 09:05 am
....Eh, it's no mistake.

Let me just clarify that I do not actually think it is a mistake. I kinda wish it was... but the likeliness is very small, practically non-existant. *stares sadly at desktop image of OAD Clone/Sakura pic*
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Kazemon15 on December 07 2007, 01:45 pm
.*stares sadly at desktop image of OAD Clone/Sakura pic*

Aww.... *pats* Go watch Say His Name and Syaoran's Memories a few times for cute CSyaoran and Sakura love. ^^ lol

Now I honestly dont know who to support..... O_O I love both Syaorans!
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: nicole_shimun on December 07 2007, 07:30 pm
huah~ arigato for the translations~ demo....... is real syaoran going to die!? :cry: hope not~  cool la, sakura calls real syaoran without -kun... wonder who's she going to end up with..... really anxious to know~ and i love the gallery pics n_n thanks so much super sailor yue san!
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 08 2007, 01:23 am
heres something that accured to me about sakura's use of syaoran's name

Show content
perhaps she's crying for the Clone... he WAS her most precous person, who she came to the dreamworld to see. perhaps she's just SHOCKED to see him  PWN rsyao like that....
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 08 2007, 02:33 am
Yes, of course, she's crying for the clone.. *rolls eyes*
She's not so heartless that she'd care more about the clone when R!Syaoran is the one getting severely burned. His LIFE is in great danger. Face it, it's him that's she's calling "Syaoran" without the suffix.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 08 2007, 04:59 am
we have to wait till the next chapter to find out who shes' crying for. it'spossible it's either one. we dont know if its a cry of dispair or a cry of horror or shock. it can be either one for either syao.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 08 2007, 05:17 am
We don't need to wait until the next chapter. It's obvious from the fact they’re on the same page when she screams his name. I don’t see how CLAMP could have made it any clearer than that.

ETA: Geez, taking a cookie from me was an incredibly mature way of responding, wasn't it? T_T
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 08 2007, 04:37 pm
i didnt take it for your opinion. i took it for the WAY you talked to me. i felt lie you were saying that im oblivious and blind to the fact.

i say it's better to just wait till the spoilers atleast. ashura or su-chan (if she behaves >.>) oughta have them up in a few hours
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: suu_no_clover on December 08 2007, 04:58 pm
We don't need to wait until the next chapter. It's obvious from the fact they’re on the same page when she screams his name. I don’t see how CLAMP could have made it any clearer than that.

ETA: Geez, taking a cookie from me was an incredibly mature way of responding, wasn't it? T_T
If you're not CLAMP, I don't see how you're in any position to say what's what. D=< Ship what you will, think what you will, but there's no need to be catty with others who have different interpretations than you. Also, taking a cookie would be a perfectly reasonable response to a harsh comment such as your earlier one.

I liked this chapter a lot. =3 The big two page pics were awesome... And I personally think it's understandable Sakura would scream for R!Syaoran, she does care for them both and seeing either of them hurt would probably be upsetting. They share the same face, and everything. xD

I'm still holding out for a good ending for the clone... it's tricky to call at this point.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Kazemon15 on December 08 2007, 05:51 pm
I liked this chapter a lot. =3 The big two page pics were awesome... And I personally think it's understandable Sakura would scream for R!Syaoran, she does care for them both and seeing either of them hurt would probably be upsetting. They share the same face, and everything. xD


lol so true. Yes, I agree, awesome chapter....and more pages to use for an angsty love triangle vid. XDD

I really hope RSyaoran doesnt get seriously hurt....the poor guy's been watching all this time through Clonie's eyes, and then to be rejected in those other chapters by Sakura, I feel for the poor guy. I hope CLAMP can give them both a happy ending. >_<
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Møon Li on December 08 2007, 07:57 pm

  It was a good chapter but... the best was shirtless Syaoran :love4: *drools*
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: ~Bloody_Rose~ on December 08 2007, 08:06 pm
oh yeah... shirtless syaoran *__*
he looked like a mean hot sexy yakuza member in that pose *drools*
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 08 2007, 09:06 pm
If you're not CLAMP, I don't see how you're in any position to say what's what. D=< Ship what you will, think what you will, but there's no need to be catty with others who have different interpretations than you. Also, taking a cookie would be a perfectly reasonable response to a harsh comment such as your earlier one.

Sailor Yue knows perfectly well why I am annoyed with her, and I'm not just talking about what she's said on this forum. She took advantage of the fact she was able to take cookies from me here.
If you have a problem with someone, isn't it better to be productive and discuss it, rather than secretly taking cookies away? Because to me, that's a very childish way of acting.

...However, seeing that everyone hates me (which is always nice for my self-esteem :[ ), I guess won't be coming back here.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: nicole_shimun on December 08 2007, 11:12 pm
well, I also agree with  the fact that sakura's calling out clonie... since there was this chapter where she had to find a magical egg thingamabob in tokyo and she said clonie's name without -kun~ demo... maybe she's calling real syaoran for once~ *sighs* n agree with the topless syaoran... there's a scan like that... I totally fell in love with it at first sight *drools~*  :inlove:
YAY FOR SYAORAN~ :noteworthy:
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 09 2007, 01:10 am
i alreacy explained why i took the cookie. and you should count yourself lucky i dont ban you for your rude behavior om hte msn group.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 09 2007, 01:30 am
MY rude behaviour? Excuse me, but you calling my opinion "crap" and in capital letters wasn't being rude?! And yes, you did say that.. In addition to something about my view making you want to bash your head against a wall.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 09 2007, 03:39 am
when did i say it was crap? i rarely diss someone's opinion outright,
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Kazemon15 on December 09 2007, 04:14 am
Hey, guys, let's not fight. We all have our own opinions. I suggest Redeternity maybe create a topic for RSyaoranxSakura shippers so no one gets in a big argument over what to ship. That way, if someone doesnt like her opinion, then they dont even have to go to that thread to read it.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 09 2007, 04:57 am
Well, you said this:

Quote
AND DONT GIVE THAT CRAP THAT
IT WAS REALLY RSYAO WHO WE FELL IN LOVE WITH.

Granted, you didn’t outright say, "your opinion is crap", but it's the same thing. And since you clearly couldn't grasp the concept I was trying to get across, you resorted to shouting at me instead.
I wasn't frustrated only at you, though. I blame the person who started that topic in the first place, since I saw that on a different thread he said "yay" to Syaoran (real) dying. >:(
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: suu_no_clover on December 09 2007, 05:28 am
Hey, guys, let's not fight. We all have our own opinions. I suggest Redeternity maybe create a topic for RSyaoranxSakura shippers so no one gets in a big argument over what to ship. That way, if someone doesnt like her opinion, then they dont even have to go to that thread to read it.
I'd totally be game for that.

And redeterinity, you and your friends said a fair amount of rude things on that msn group, yourself. "lol you disagree with me, therefore you don't know how to understand literature". It's awfully similar to what she said to you, so it does go both ways.

edit: Whoo, 1000 posts... took me long enough.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 09 2007, 05:30 am
and i DID say in that thread that the caps was an accident.

@ suu i LOVE your chibis XD so cute
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 09 2007, 05:57 am
How can typing in caps like that be an "accident"? Your post is mostly in lower case letters except for that one bit.. You can't seriously be telling me you pressed the key down inadvertently? ¬¬
(..And anyway, there is such a thing as a delete/backspace key, you know..)

"lol you disagree with me, therefore you don't know how to understand literature".

I believe she was referring to the way that people kept ignoring my points and the evidence I had to back it up, and instead just repeated (more aggressively) things they'd already mentioned like, "he was there from the start therefore she loves him!!1" that I had already argued against.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 09 2007, 06:05 am
Quote
How can typing in caps like that be an "accident"? Your post is mostly in lower case letters except for that one bit.. You can't seriously be telling me you pressed the key down inadvertently?

it's called capslock. i type fast and sometimes brush aganst it. and i DIDNT delete my post because im lazy. id rather NOT retype a message over again over a stray mistake by my pink finger.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: redeternity on December 09 2007, 06:27 am
i type fast and sometimes brush aganst it.

No, I'm sorry. I don't buy that excuse. That particular sentence was in capitals, and oddly enough, the rest wasn't.

id rather NOT retype a message over again

You wouldn't have to re-type the whole message (ever tried Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V?), just the part that you made a mistake in.
Regardless, I wasn't actually talking about deleting the entire post.. Don't you ever check over what you’ve written before you send it? And if you don't.. You should.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Kazemon15 on December 09 2007, 06:31 am
I'd totally be game for that.

Yeah, I'd defaintly go to that thread, I kinda love real a little more than clonie. XD Im so sorry, clonie!
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Møon Li on December 09 2007, 07:09 am

 Sorry to interrupt your talking but...

n agree with the topless syaoran... there's a scan like that... I totally fell in love with it at first sight *drools~*  :inlove:
YAY FOR SYAORAN~ :noteworthy:
:O Where?? you meant the one in the manga or there's another one better? hoho.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: nicole_shimun on December 09 2007, 11:53 am
well, its in the manga alright~ demo... i think you've seen it before in chaptire 164~ pose by the waterfall *drools n blushes* :inlove: :inlove: :inlove: kore wa desu~  o(n_n)o And another thing....ano, suu no clover san, your icon and banner is so cute! do u have the original picture? sorry for asking ne~
(http://i182.photobucket.com/albums/x135/nicoleshimun_123/01.jpg)
http://i182.photobucket.com/albums/x135/nicoleshimun_123/01.jpg
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: nicole_shimun on December 09 2007, 11:59 am
moon li san~ your icon and banner really gets into the christmas mood n_n! *sigh* all u guys' icons and banners are so cool! o(>.<)o few more weeks to christmas! can't wait for the day to come~ gingerbread men! here i come~
and sailor yue san :)... can i join the msn group?? or is it just among friends only?
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 09 2007, 12:27 pm
you can go to it. links are in my siggie.
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: nicole_shimun on December 09 2007, 01:49 pm
arigato gozaimas sailor yue san!
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Møon Li on December 09 2007, 06:41 pm
well, its in the manga alright~ demo... i think you've seen it before in chaptire 164~ pose by the waterfall *drools n blushes* :inlove: :inlove: :inlove: kore wa desu~  o(n_n)o And another thing....ano, suu no clover san, your icon and banner is so cute! do u have the original picture? sorry for asking ne~
(http://i182.photobucket.com/albums/x135/nicoleshimun_123/01.jpg)
http://i182.photobucket.com/albums/x135/nicoleshimun_123/01.jpg
Oooh that one yes hehe... though I still prefer the shittless in chapter 174 <3 *drools* and I'm glad you like my sig and avi! ;D
Title: Re: chapter 175
Post by: Sailor Yue-chan on December 09 2007, 07:06 pm
carefull of your typing. you realize what that says XDDD

i just got e an xmassy siggie.