CapturedWings.org Forums

CLAMP's Famous Works => Cardcaptor Sakura => Topic started by: riku-chan on October 17 2005, 02:12 am

Title: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: riku-chan on October 17 2005, 02:12 am: Did you like the anime end better or manga ending for CCS?

I liked the manga ending for CCS much much better than the anime. but i still really liked the anime too. Just when syaoran came back after a while and suprised Sakura.. ahh so lovely! I love syaorna so very much..
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Shadeslayer on October 17 2005, 03:42 am: Aaah! That's a hard question...both of the endings are SO kawaii! *squeals* But if I had to choose one, I guess I'd say the Manga ending. *coughgrown-up Syaoran!!!cough* :inlove:
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Arcademan on October 17 2005, 03:52 am: Manga...no comparison to me :wink:
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: moezychan on October 17 2005, 04:22 am: That's a hard one. I mean I like the anime better than the manga, but if I had to choose, I do like the manga ending better. I got my closure with that one. I need closure. Pardon the pun, but they didn't leave anything hanging. That's includes Sakura! Still, the anime ending was much funnier though. But manga first.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Moon on October 17 2005, 04:40 am: I'd say the manga ending. But I also liked the anime ending, too. Yet the manga ending was sweet and.. I just love it! ^w^
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Cardcaptor Takato on October 17 2005, 04:48 am: I know I'll probably get killed for saying this, but personally I thought the manga's ending was a little bit cheesy. Everything was almost just too perfect. If they didn't show that epiloge part with Shaoran returning as a teenager, I would have liked it more, but because they did I liked the anime's ending better. There's just something about that scene where Sakura runs towards Shaoran shouting out "I love you!" that gets you excited, you know? And having the series being a little more open ended makes for interesting message board discussions and fanfics because it makes you want to speculate what happens next.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: riku-chan on October 17 2005, 05:13 am: yea you do have a good point there.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: bLuetopaz on October 17 2005, 03:54 pm: i would prefer the manga ending.. at least they really concluded what happened at the end..
Show content
Sakura and Syaoran end up hugging one another = being together

the anime ending leaves you wondering are they or are they not..
Show content
:angry: i hate to guess
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: augustserenade on October 17 2005, 03:59 pm: The manga of course.
Everything was pretty much answered in that version.
The anime ending (both the movie and the series) kind of left me wondering...
^^
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Strawberry on October 18 2005, 03:44 am: I like the Manga ending better because it is more emotional on the SxS feelings.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Adarian on October 22 2005, 11:05 am: I actually would have to agree with Takato on this. I thought the manga's ending was almost watered down and kind of strengthed its believability. Although, it still was pretty good, but it was almost anti-climatic compared to the rest of story in my opinion.

But I've always been a fan of open-ended stuff. I like how the fans have more options in their fanfics and stuff, so I guess I just liked the open endedness of the anime.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Ralea on October 22 2005, 01:36 pm: Definitely manga ending. Ah, the 2nd movie ending was a cliffhanger...literally..(haha).
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: babypigggy on October 24 2005, 07:21 am: The manga is cuter ^_^ the anime one..kinda leaves you hanging...He leaves then...nothing...
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Lexi on October 24 2005, 08:24 am: I adore both endings, but I would have to go with the manga ending since SÃ—S hugged and were happily together forever :love5:~~~Â

It was sort of similar in the anime, yet I didn't like how the ending felt a bit "unfinished" -_-
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: suu_no_clover on October 24 2005, 12:22 pm: Manga ending. Let's face it -
Syaoran is a schmexy little thing when he's older. :inlove: The best part of the whole series was the last 3 pages. :keke:
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Arcademan on October 24 2005, 12:41 pm: (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch534.jpg)
Page 1 (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch534.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch535.jpg)
Page 2 (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch535.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch536.jpg)
Page 3 (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch536.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch537.jpg)
Page 4 (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch537.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch538.jpg)
Final Page Spread (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v20/Arcademan/Comix/ch538.jpg)

Click the links under the pictures for the full-sized pages.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: D.J.P on October 24 2005, 12:45 pm: thanks for that Arcademan,

I need to get the final book yet (our distributor has only released the first 5 of master of the clow : :angry:)

And then I need to get Cardcaptor Sakura set

- Looks like I have to buy the rest from the US :angry:
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Arcademan on October 24 2005, 01:09 pm: There are 2 CCSakura sets out now in the U.S.

The original which was smaller and done American comic book style and the re-release by TokyoPop done the traditional manga style with all the original artwork intact. The new books can be bought seperate or in two 3-book sets with bookcase covers to hold all 6 books. Those cost $29.99 a set.

The other books (originally $9.99 each) can be found cheap on eBay. Bought my set for about $25 awhile back on there :wink:
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: moezychan on October 24 2005, 01:09 pm: Aww, arigatou Arcademan-sama! That was very touching and considerate! It's been a while since I read that! Such a kirei (pretty) ending.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: D.J.P on October 24 2005, 01:35 pm: Cool, I'll remember to get the Toykopop ones then (gotta wait till I have money :cry:)
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Mina on October 26 2005, 11:27 am: Definitly manga. I dunno, I was statisfied with the anime ending... in manga, it was just so... cute... it melt my heart away. Anime's ending didn't have that effect on me...
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Robin Sena on October 26 2005, 10:09 pm: Depends.

Some wants a closure, Manga does that.

Others want to have many possibilities, Anime does that.

Gee, it's a tough one(I like both qualities).
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Kuro-puppy on November 09 2005, 09:20 pm: anime ending 'cause when void was captured and syaoran was 'attacked'
she told him she loved him and when he said nothing my heart stopped

*i was like NNOOOOO!!!! Void erased his memory!* and she started crying and
stuff and when he responded and said her name i was even more happy and
relieved than Sakura.

And then the jump....it is a classic :noteworthy:

the manga ending is very good as well but i go for anime
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: cute_me on November 10 2005, 10:39 am: manga ending :)
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Eriol on November 24 2005, 06:35 pm: Pretty hard question...ne but I like the both ending of CCSakura 'cause in manga,it have long line but have broad possibility of good ending but in anime,even though it have neutral storyline but a satisified and awesome ending!!!! :hehe:
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Hikari B. on December 03 2005, 03:55 am: I love the manga ending! ^________^
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: selenityshiroi on December 10 2005, 02:03 am: My biggest gripe about the anime was that they removed one of the most important plot pieces ::
Show content
of Fujitaka being the other half of Clow's reincarnation, and since he fell asleep under Eriol's spell they removed any possibility of it being real in the animeverse
::Â That killed the end of the anime for me.Â But I did like the second movie, too.Â The manga was beautiful, and I loved the ending so I suppose that wins.

I think that the anime ended well for the anime and the manga ended well for the manga.Â The manga ending may have seemed less climatic, but the anime had more action in it anyway (52 cards compared to 19).Â The manga had less action anyway, so the ending was more suitable.

I suppose my ultimate ending would be an addition to the second movie!Â Sakura should realise that Syaoran's visit in Japan is near it's end, rush to make him a teddy bear and run to the bus stop to give it to him (whilst Meilin and Tomoyo fawn in the bus and bushes respectively!).Â Then they can have the reunion as teenagers!Â (Of course, that doesn't change that they removed the spoiler aboveÂ :hmp:).

Selenity
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Hikari B. on December 10 2005, 10:19 am: Quote from: selenityshiroi on December 10 2005, 02:03 am
My biggest gripe about the anime was that they removed one of the most important plot pieces ::
Show content
of Fujitaka being the other half of Clow's reincarnation, and since he fell asleep under Eriol's spell they removed any possibility of it being real in the animeverse
:: That killed the end of the anime for me. But I did like the second movie, too. The manga was beautiful, and I loved the ending so I suppose that wins.

I think that the anime ended well for the anime and the manga ended well for the manga. The manga ending may have seemed less climatic, but the anime had more action in it anyway (52 cards compared to 19). The manga had less action anyway, so the ending was more suitable.

I suppose my ultimate ending would be an addition to the second movie! Sakura should realise that Syaoran's visit in Japan is near it's end, rush to make him a teddy bear and run to the bus stop to give it to him (whilst Meilin and Tomoyo fawn in the bus and bushes respectively!). Then they can have the reunion as teenagers! (Of course, that doesn't change that they removed the spoiler above :hmp:).

Selenity

I go with that idea! They could at least put in a clip of that after the credits!
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: Miss Jenni-Maie on December 10 2005, 10:22 am: I liked the Manga a tad more. I'm not exactly sure why. I've always found I like mangas more compared to animes.
I loved the anime ending, don't get me wrong. I just thought that the movie wasn't especially neccesary except for getting S&S together.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: ~Bloody_Rose~ on December 16 2005, 11:04 pm: The mange ending.. coz in the CCS Movie "The sealed card", sakura-chan jumped to Syaoran-kun and said "I LOVE YOU!!!"... she hasn't been able to hug syaoran-kun coz Ashita e no Merodii already played... it was like * I LOVE YOU!!! [jumps] todokete kono koe wo...* (right?) annoying!! But ofcourse it's obvious that they hugged at the last part... The manga ending is cute... much much much much better than the anime ending...
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: * i z z y * on December 20 2005, 02:46 pm: Quote from: -=kuro_woof=- on December 16 2005, 11:04 pm
The mange ending.. coz in the CCS Movie "The sealed card", sakura-chan jumped to Syaoran-kun and said "I LOVE YOU!!!"... she hasn't been able to hug syaoran-kun coz Ashita e no Merodii already played... it was like * I LOVE YOU!!! [jumps] todokete kono koe wo...* (right?) annoying!! But ofcourse it's obvious that they hugged at the last part... The manga ending is cute... much much much much better than the anime ending...

I agree! The manga ending was much more sweeter. Very adorable as well. I practically squealed when I saw the picture of S+S hugging.
Title: Re: What CCS ending did you like better?
Post by: >>pooJa<< on December 29 2005, 01:11 am: It's tough to decide.. Manga ending is soooo cuutee!! ^___^ But anime ending's really kawaii too!! .. This is tough..