CLAMP's Famous Works > Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE
Tsubasa OVA: Tsubasa TOKYO REVELATIONS
Sailor Yue-chan:
=P
thanks for warning about the MKR anime. i started reading the manga, but didnt really get past the part where the girls meat the 700 year old dwarf XP id like to pick it back up sometime. but the way you said, ill stay clear of the anime/oav XD
sometimes adaptations are good, sometimes their bad. the holic anime adaptation is good. they keep to the canon, but at diferent angles (IE: the twin girls arc; the ceremony with that wine tree)
some production companies destroy cano, others keep to it, but diferently. TOEI did a good job with Sailor Moon... the manga is totaly dark, but the anime has its lighter moments, and you get a chance to get to know and like the amazon trio, hwhereas the manga version they dont last more than a chapter XP. tho i dont think many moonies liked how they changed the Stars saga... i never read that part of hte manga (did that part ever get published?) but id've liked too,
i think TOEI did a good job with Zatch bell i guess. never read the manga, nor am i a fangirl, but the anime is pretty cool too. i just really hate Folgore's VA (and character all together. XD)
i guess some production companies are better than others. it just depends on severak things =S
Kazemon15:
--- Quote from: Super Sailor Yue on July 18 2007, 02:32 pm --- =P
thanks for warning about the MKR anime. i started reading the manga, but didnt really get past the part where the girls meat the 700 year old dwarf XP id like to pick it back up sometime. but the way you said, ill stay clear of the anime/oav XD
sometimes adaptations are good, sometimes their bad. the holic anime adaptation is good. they keep to the canon, but at diferent angles (IE: the twin girls arc; the ceremony with that wine tree)
some production companies destroy cano, others keep to it, but diferently. TOEI did a good job with Sailor Moon... the manga is totaly dark, but the anime has its lighter moments, and you get a chance to get to know and like the amazon trio, hwhereas the manga version they dont last more than a chapter XP. tho i dont think many moonies liked how they changed the Stars saga... i never read that part of hte manga (did that part ever get published?) but id've liked too,
i think TOEI did a good job with Zatch bell i guess. never read the manga, nor am i a fangirl, but the anime is pretty cool too. i just really hate Folgore's VA (and character all together. XD)
i guess some production companies are better than others. it just depends on severak things =S
--- End quote ---
Actually....the author who did Sailor Moon hated the whole animation production of the work. Sailor Moon also changed the whole story completely from the manga....at the end of the manga, it was all wrapped up and explained where everything came from....the ending of Stars didnt. But I like the anime better because it had more character development....which is why I like all anime in general....just because it's a filler episode, there's more development in it...and I felt the same way for Tsubasa anime....even though some fillers were stupid (bus arc) but the others were good, it showed their more human side of things....I mean, come on, CCS Syaoran was more likable because of his faults....in Chaos arc, he had a struggle with himself about doing the right thing, which is more human. Alot of ppl hate TRC Syaoran because he's "too perfect" ....which is why I think Beetrain tried to make him a little less perfect and in my point of view, it worked and made him more likable to me.
And even though MKR was different from the manga, I still would advise watching it....it had a better wrap-up than the manga did, in my view. And if it werent for the MKR anime, the Kiisimi in TRC would have never appeared in TRC since she was an anime original in MKR and an interesting baddie.
What I'm saying it, just because it doesnt follow EXACTLY what the manga is doesnt make it bad, so please, stop dissing BeeTrain.....dissing BeeTrain in my eyes looks like you're saying all the works it did are horrible.
The term "anime" in my eyes means "just a different way of telling the series" .....for instance.....The Digimon Manga is way off from the Anime....but I liked seeing a different view of it...the same view of something you know what is going to happen might be boring animated...so sometimes they change it to make it more interesting. (aka, Sakura vanishing with Syaoran in ep 23, I found that better than the manga itself, showed a closer bond)
Except....it would have been better not to kill Eagle in the 2nd to last ep....*goes fangirlish* POOR EAGLE! (sadly, I liked him better than Lantis....)
Now, back to the OVA....I am still nitpicking about Sakura's eyes, damnit....they're NEON GREEN....what the hell? They're supposed to be EMERALD GREEN. Shame on you. IG....just like in Tales of Destiny 2, you kep changing the colors slightly in each animation sequence....
(btw, as a hardcore Tales fan (most Tales openings done by BT) I take the insultment of that company more to heart)
I also think CLAMP and BeeTrain should work together for one reason....no offense to both, but they both suck at battle sequences....Kurogane never showed any other attack other than Hama Ryoujin.....MKR, Hikaru kept using Fire Arrow for the past 6 volumes....and most of their works are slow paced. In X, only two characters died...and it's like what, 18 volumes already?
Sailor Yue-chan:
bad beetrain animation: medabots. its got seriously crude drawing >< the storyline was decent tho (save for season 3. that all but SUCKED.)
understandably, those who worship the manga canon cring at terribleness of animes. =P
atleast with CLAMP working on production, and since they did the writing of the script... the OAV will pretty much stick to canon =3
Kazemon15:
--- Quote from: Super Sailor Yue on July 18 2007, 04:06 pm ---bad beetrain animation: medabots. its got seriously crude drawing >< the storyline was decent tho (save for season 3. that all but SUCKED.)
understandably, those who worship the manga canon cring at terribleness of animes. =P
atleast with CLAMP working on production, and since they did the writing of the script... the OAV will pretty much stick to canon =3
--- End quote ---
I just feel sorry for you for missing out on other things because of your close mindedness toward anything that is not so-called "canon" (whatever the hell that means, because nothing is "canon" yet anyway)
My view of a true anime fan would accept any kind of storytelling reguardless. And of course older anime would not be as well animated as newer anime. Storyline is what makes an anime an anime, not how it is animated. I seen some fancy animated animes before but the storyline was so damn boring, I stopped watching it (aka, Scrapped Princess, it's only pretty to look at).
And I doubt BeeTrain just did solely one anime which you are basing on. Please try to look for the better not the worst part....I can put in some works IG and Madhouse did horribly on too if you want to get technical. If you're going to complain, I would like to see you do a better version then.
If you are so dedicated to the manga, then I say just stick only to the manga to save yourself and others from being bothered by complaints and rants/disappointments.
Since CLAMP has more power now, of course they would jump in to making their adaption perfect. Just like Rowling did for some of the Harry Potter movies.
Sandra-chan:
Of course an anime adaption can't be exactly like the manga, then it wouldn't be as much fun. In my point of view the Tsubasa anime didn't only change the story a bit and added a couple of fillers they changed the story and the characters alot and half of the second season was fillers, (and mostly bad fillers too). It was okay sometimes in the first season but after that it went bad.
The fillers was mostly useless, I don't see that they had any character development, instead they changed the characters personalites in them. For example they made Kurogane look ridicoulos in the chibi episode (and some other episodes too) and made him look stupid many times, but he isn't. And they made him much more happy go lucky, he even humms in one episode - would the Kurogane in the manga ever do that? And Sakura and Syaoran, they say each others names a hundred times....
Of course you get upset some if an anime adaption of an manga you really like and if you had alot of expectations on and then it goes downhill and isn't at all what you imagied. If you look closely at the anime you can see than they have censored all the time, for example Fei wong Reed's soldiers aren't human they are robots etc so the it will be less bloodshed etc........ In short thay made it much more a series for children. And Mokona is huge, and that I think is a pity, he is supposed to be so cute and small.
I'm not saying all Bee-trains work is bad, it isn't all their fault, the channel is to blame too.
Everyone has the right to have their own opinions, and I don't like the anime. And Kazemon15 it seems like you think that you shouldn't complain about anime but still you're complaining about the eyecolour IG gave Sakura. -_-
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version