General Discussions > Anything goes...
The Post Thread IX (AKA The Meaningless Thread)
Robin Sena:
Actually, the scoring system is a combination of critic and fan votings.
Around 60% Fans
40% Critics (which includes me)
Points are scored by positive reviews, minus for negative. The formula is a bit complicated (I have to use a calculator!)
Naruto and TRC pulled in fourth and fifth place because of the huge Fan vote factor (the two got the highest points fan-wise), but can't match the high critic praise for the Top 3.
Though right now there are talks of removing the Gold Award for TRC...
Konata Izumi:
hehe... good thing the fan vote factor kept TRC and Naruto on teh 4th and 5th place....
But What i don't understand is why score of critics are important as well, as in, the judges would have used 70/30 just to be a bit more democratic and pro-fan based... Besides, what the critics say are just mere opinion, I don't think it will have any effect on what the fans will say about the anime... (No harm intended, Robin-Sama, just saying my views ^_^;;)
Robin Sena:
Elysia Silvermoon - Well we tried going 30/70. Unfortunately it got abused (resulting in a huge mess up during the 2002-2003 votings.).
Kidou Gundam Seed won by a huge landslide in 2002, and X in 2003. Even the fans say the thing was too unbalanced.
Since we change voting rules every year, I think I'm going for 35/65.
monkey:
--- Quote from: Robin Sena on May 20 2006, 08:19 pm ---Actually, the scoring system is a combination of critic and fan votings.
Around 60% Fans
40% Critics (which includes me)
Points are scored by positive reviews, minus for negative. The formula is a bit complicated (I have to use a calculator!)
Naruto and TRC pulled in fourth and fifth place because of the huge Fan vote factor (the two got the highest points fan-wise), but can't match the high critic praise for the Top 3.
Though right now there are talks of removing the Gold Award for TRC...
--- End quote ---
so is this official or unofficial?
--- Quote from: VexNet on May 20 2006, 08:46 am ---where are these results from?
Are they fan voted or officially voted (i.e magazine or acual awards show)
--- End quote ---
Robin Sena:
Unofficial of course! (though what are you reffering as official, I think you mean the magazine reports?)
Come on, you're talking about ordinary anime fans (like me) forming a community that extends beyond the forum.
It's fun to brainstorm on reviews (and wage war if you need to) with different views.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version